Survivor 38, Episode 1
"IT SMELLS LIKE SUCCESS"
I think I'm not going to long-recap this season. Just going to blog the highlights and mymoaning and bitching thoughts.
It's a new season of Survivor, everyone! *somersaults*
But I want to pause this happiness for a bit because I want to whine and start this off on the wrong foot.
I enjoyed Fans vs Favourites and Blood vs Water. I don't mind the returnees-mixed-with-newbies seasons and the redemption island twist on Blood vs Water. I understand the drama and gameplay these twists could bring to those seasons.
But Redemption Island, South Pacific and Philippines (we've long snuffed Guatemala) and the redemption island twist on the first two are just eye-rolling to me. You won't admit it, Survivor, but most of these seasons were totally made around your hugely hyped returnees, your favourite children from past seasons that you want to see finally winning.
So I don't get the appeal of having the four returnees on this season -- those who've already played twice, even more. Will I feel differently if we had my favourite returnees instead? I don't think so. I can't think of anyone who I'd like to see badly enough to return in this format. Returnees can return to Fans vs Favourites, Blood vs Water, or an all-returnee season. But in this set of four, for no reason other than their Survivor careers have been hyped so much, and on top of that you slip them a surprise bonus island too? No.
Maybe it's the dynamic. When these returnees and newbies are placed in the same tribe, the former are pushed as heroes first before competitors. Don't make me watch a mentoring show, please.
I might have enjoyed these returnees at some point in their old seasons, but seriously, how many more times do you want to shove Joe, just saying one name here, to our faces?
I'll smack yours if you say, "Don't watch it, then."
Image: CBS
I think I'm not going to long-recap this season. Just going to blog the highlights and my
_____
It's a new season of Survivor, everyone! *somersaults*
But I want to pause this happiness for a bit because I want to whine and start this off on the wrong foot.
I enjoyed Fans vs Favourites and Blood vs Water. I don't mind the returnees-mixed-with-newbies seasons and the redemption island twist on Blood vs Water. I understand the drama and gameplay these twists could bring to those seasons.
But Redemption Island, South Pacific and Philippines (we've long snuffed Guatemala) and the redemption island twist on the first two are just eye-rolling to me. You won't admit it, Survivor, but most of these seasons were totally made around your hugely hyped returnees, your favourite children from past seasons that you want to see finally winning.
So I don't get the appeal of having the four returnees on this season -- those who've already played twice, even more. Will I feel differently if we had my favourite returnees instead? I don't think so. I can't think of anyone who I'd like to see badly enough to return in this format. Returnees can return to Fans vs Favourites, Blood vs Water, or an all-returnee season. But in this set of four, for no reason other than their Survivor careers have been hyped so much, and on top of that you slip them a surprise bonus island too? No.
Maybe it's the dynamic. When these returnees and newbies are placed in the same tribe, the former are pushed as heroes first before competitors. Don't make me watch a mentoring show, please.
I might have enjoyed these returnees at some point in their old seasons, but seriously, how many more times do you want to shove Joe, just saying one name here, to our faces?
I'll smack yours if you say, "Don't watch it, then."
Image: CBS

Comments