I’m Rooting for Widow’s Bay for the Emmys
For someone who prefers to see absolutely no one unless I want to, I think living on an island of 3,000 people is not sustainable – let alone one with no mobile coverage, reliable electricity or my must-have shops. Possibly, it’s more about mobile coverage and stuff than people.
Even worse for those who were born on the island, the lore says they can’t leave. What if they want to go to uni or learn something new that the small, isolated town cannot provide, or work in a despicable AI company in another part of the country – all of which I'm either not keen on or hate, btw. So, thinking about it, this place is actually almost perfect for me.
Widow’s Bay is a fictional New England island town with over 300 years of history, which is mostly the horror kind. The current mayor, Tom Loftis (Matthew Ryhs), is determined to bring tourists to the island to boost its struggling economy, even when it feels like at least 78% of the universe is working against him.
The backstory is, the founder of the island made a pact with a devil entity hundreds of years ago, so his people could survive the famine during their first winter. Since then, whenever it requires, the town will have to make human sacrifices to the devil, or they are not going to have a peaceful life. Thankfully, this tradition has not been properly conveyed to the next generations – or probably was shut down some time decades earlier – so no one seems to know anything about it. I mean, at least from what we’ve seen in season 1. I don’t know if we’re going to be introduced to a secret selection committee in season 2, which would be horrible.
But the stories about the island’s curses linger, blurring into rumours and myths and normal lives. So, no official sacrifices have been made for a while. Then come present time, the moment the island is called “the next Martha Vineyard”, the curses are waking up.
The best things about Widow’s Bay are the writing, the comedy and the cast.
Matthew Rhys delivers Tom's struggles and comedic timing in every scene. I feel for him when he has to defend the island at every turn, like the town's "checkered past" of cannibalism, when those people in 1786 did not, in fact, immediately turn to cannibalism when they were trapped in the church – it took them four days!
And I love the rest of the characters too. I’m rooting for each of these clumsy souls. This is going to be a very long post if I were to name everyone, so I’m just going to name a few:
Wyck (Stephen Root) is a curmudgeon who has no patience for almost anyone and will say things like “Five minutes. I don’t want you correcting my grammar. I don’t have time to sit here and go tit for tit with you.” Lmao. Garrett (Fred Robbins) is the town’s lighthouse keeper who probably has two scenes in the series, but they are all hilarious, they make you cackle in the middle of seeing an incoming tornado. Rosemary (Dale Dickey), a town hall staffer, is so deadpan and realistic and chill, I want to be her best friend. Bechir (Kevin Carroll), the town’s sheriff, is probably the slightly saner one, constantly at his wits’ end, trying to herd everyone. And Kingston Rumi Southwick is the perfect Evan, a teenager who’d smile and say yes in front of his father but ask for an emergency ladder out of his bedroom from his elderly sitter “in case of fire”. Then we have Patricia (Kate O’Flynn), Tom’s assistant, fighting ageism and holding the town together with her 2%-charged taser.
And for a comedy horror, the comedy part is so satisfying.
Widow’s Bay is nominated in 19 categories at the upcoming 2026 Emmys. I don’t know all of them, but I want them to win all the acting categories they are in, the writing and directing categories, and the Outstanding Comedy Series (although, unfortunately, Dickey and O'Flynn are in the same one).
(I’m also going to recap the season, I think, before season 2 because, as usual, study notes.)
Image: apple.com

Comments