Heated Rivalry: People, We Can Leave Things Undiagnosed
I’ve been a fan of the books for a long time, but I didn't know they were making the show, not until a day before it aired. So that was the best surprise. And boy, was it so good. Thank universe for Jacob Tierney for his craft and vision and care for the series. Rachel Reid, and the entire cast and crew are inspiring.
Post-season 1, I saw on Twitter, apparently Rachel had said that Shane is autistic. It’s fine if Shane is autistic, and representation matters, but I wish we didn't have this need to diagnose everything. I think it’s also ok to be messy, awkward, chaotic, nervous, quirky, super-organized or focused (or total opposite), and stubborn as a reaction or personality trait. Since when does everyone have to be smooth and have things all figured out all the time if they are not neurodivergent?
Why would we want the same, predictable, non-complex, non-nuanced, cookie-cutter characters across all the stories we consume? How is that interesting?
Not everything has to have a name, a box, a constant attention, a medication or a colour.
As at now, Shane’s neurodivergence is not canon in either the books or the show. And part of the fun of discussing books, TV shows and movies is the way we interpret what’s happening in them. But my heart sank when I heard Rachel is writing the third Shane and Ilya book. Don’t get me wrong. I looove that there is going to be a third book. As long as there is a story to tell, make as many of them as you want. I just dread thinking now Rachel is going to confirm the autism diagnosis.
And don’t get me started with the streets diagnosing Shane’s strict diet as an eating disorder. Everyone, we really don’t have to be overdramatic this way. People can have a strange diet for as simple a reason as having a different taste.
Then before I write this post, I looked for the exact quote from Rachel about Shane’s autism. I found one from a Reddit AMA:
“When I wrote Heated Rivalry, I wasn’t specifically thinking about Shane being neurodivergent because I wasn’t particularly informed about that sort of thing. He was just uptight/anxious/focused etc. I then went through the long and complicated journey of getting my neurodivergent oldest child diagnosed, and I learned a lot then, and since. So by the time I wrote The Long Game, I had a better understanding of Shane, I think, and I realized that, yeah, he’s probably autistic. But I also doubt he’ll ever realize it himself.”
He’s probably autistic. But I also doubt he’ll ever realize it himself.
Ok, I can get behind that. With enough blackmails. And it gives me hope that it’s going to be left unconfirmed.
We can let people be different from others without stamping them with a condition.
And I’m saying this as someone who is often messy, awkward, chaotic, nervous, quirky, super-organized or focused (or at other times, a total opposite), and stubborn myself. Oh, don’t try with “Well, maybe…” I’ve just written a whole page about this. I’ll throw something at you.
_____
(Next time, let's talk about how some people are falling over themselves to dissect women and what we like as if our interests were some kind of skin rash: life choices, careers, marriages, clothes we wear and for some of us *checks notes* "gay smut".)
Image: Accent Aigu Entertainment, Bell Media

Comments