All Quiet on the Western Front
Directed by the same director, Edward Berger, Conclave brought me to this movie. So, the beautiful, painting-like cinematography and the attention to details as a way of storytelling are no surprise. But this third movie adaptation of the book, in short, is just omg brutal 🫠. I could only watch it a few minutes at a time.
The year is 1917. Seventeen-year-old Paul joins the German Army alongside his friends Ludwig, Albert and Franz to fight in WWI. Once they reach the front line, the merciless reality of the trench warfare snaps the naivete and enthusiasm out of them. It brings nothing but gory and heartbreaking deaths in a stupid formula: you cross to the other side's trenches and kill every single man in them. Then the other side will do the same to you.
Eighteen months later, these kids are seasoned soldiers. They have lost friends and make new friends and sometimes get to leave the trenches for five minutes, where we'll be reminded of the humanity on both sides. These soldiers come with family, friends, dreams and personalities; and they also long for a normal life. War is pointless. Senseless destruction and deaths in the millions on both sides, for what? What's so difficult about not hurting others?
The Allies and the German commanders drag their feet and sign for an armistice eventually. But what are another several thousand of actual human lives that could have been saved to these deranged war bosses. The ceasefire that is set at 11AM, 11 November 1918, also means their German General can order an ambush out of spite at 10.45AM when both sides are in a good mood to get out of the war alive. So these soldiers march back to the front to kill the people that they probably have more things in common with -- people who have also been trying to just survive the war -- than they do with their well-fed, warmly clothed military leaders.
But the most heartbreaking scene to me has to be the 10 minutes when Paul and his friend Kat from his unit venture out to steal food from a farm. The armistice news has been announced by that time. The two laugh and joke and talk about their plan once they are home. Then, the menacingly serene score starts to play in the background over a supposedly joyful, goofy scene -- of two hungry soldiers stealing eggs in the final hours of the war. You know nothing good is coming out of this scene. And nothing did.
Image: Netflix
The year is 1917. Seventeen-year-old Paul joins the German Army alongside his friends Ludwig, Albert and Franz to fight in WWI. Once they reach the front line, the merciless reality of the trench warfare snaps the naivete and enthusiasm out of them. It brings nothing but gory and heartbreaking deaths in a stupid formula: you cross to the other side's trenches and kill every single man in them. Then the other side will do the same to you.
Eighteen months later, these kids are seasoned soldiers. They have lost friends and make new friends and sometimes get to leave the trenches for five minutes, where we'll be reminded of the humanity on both sides. These soldiers come with family, friends, dreams and personalities; and they also long for a normal life. War is pointless. Senseless destruction and deaths in the millions on both sides, for what? What's so difficult about not hurting others?
The Allies and the German commanders drag their feet and sign for an armistice eventually. But what are another several thousand of actual human lives that could have been saved to these deranged war bosses. The ceasefire that is set at 11AM, 11 November 1918, also means their German General can order an ambush out of spite at 10.45AM when both sides are in a good mood to get out of the war alive. So these soldiers march back to the front to kill the people that they probably have more things in common with -- people who have also been trying to just survive the war -- than they do with their well-fed, warmly clothed military leaders.
But the most heartbreaking scene to me has to be the 10 minutes when Paul and his friend Kat from his unit venture out to steal food from a farm. The armistice news has been announced by that time. The two laugh and joke and talk about their plan once they are home. Then, the menacingly serene score starts to play in the background over a supposedly joyful, goofy scene -- of two hungry soldiers stealing eggs in the final hours of the war. You know nothing good is coming out of this scene. And nothing did.
Image: Netflix

Comments